Stock Market Insights

Does Maintaining Separate Demat & Trading Accounts Help?

Having a combined Demat & trading account might be convenient, but there are some advantages to maintaining them separately.

Imagine you're a chef running a busy restaurant. You have a large fridge to store all of your ingredients, but sometimes it gets crowded, making it difficult to find what you need quickly.

Now, let's say you start a catering service on the side, and you could use the same fridge for your restaurant and catering business. But it could get very crowded and disorganised. Plus, accidentally using the wrong ingredients for a dish could ruin the entire meal and cost you money.

This example could apply to your trading and investing journey as well. While you could use the same Demat account to both trade and invest, there are certainly arguments for using two separate accounts.

So, what are the pros and cons of maintaining separate Demat accounts for trading and investing? Let’s find out!

When Do You Require a Demat Account and a Trading Account?

First, let's understand the difference between Trading and Demat accounts.

A Trading account is used to buy and sell securities in the stock market, such as shares, futures, and options.

On the other hand, a Demat account is used to hold securities in electronic form, eliminating the need for physical share certificates. When you buy a stock, the shares are credited to your demat account, and when you sell them, the shares are debited from your Demat account.

If you want to invest in stocks for the long term, you will need a Demat account to hold the shares. However, if you're going to trade in the stock market actively, you will need a trading account to buy and sell securities. Most of India's brokers offer Demat and Trading accounts together, while others may offer them separately.

Pros of Having Separate Accounts for Trading and Investing

1. Better organisation:

Separating your trading and investing activities into two accounts allows you to keep your finances more organised. This can help you track your profits and losses separately for both activities, making it easier to analyse your performance and make more informed decisions.

2. More control over risk:

When you maintain separate accounts, you can control your risk exposure better. For example, you can set different stop-loss orders or position sizes for each account, depending on your risk tolerance and investment objectives.

3. Tax benefits:

If you maintain separate accounts, you can take advantage of tax benefits. For example, you can claim deductions for trading losses in one account while holding long-term investments in another.

4. Reduced emotional bias:

By separating your trading and investing activities, you can reduce the emotional bias from combining the two. This can help you make more rational decisions and avoid emotional trading mistakes.

5. Customized strategies:

By maintaining separate accounts, you can develop customised strategies for both trading and investing. For example, you may adopt a more aggressive trading strategy in one account while maintaining a more conservative, long-term investment strategy in another. This can help you better achieve your overall financial goals.

Cons of Having Separate Accounts for Trading and Investing

However, there are some drawbacks to maintaining separate accounts.

1. Increased complexity:

Maintaining separate accounts can increase the complexity of managing your finances. You may need to track and manage two different sets of fees, commissions, and account balances, which can be time-consuming and challenging.

2. Higher costs:

Maintaining two separate accounts may also result in higher costs, as you may need to pay fees and commissions for each account. This can eat into your profits and reduce your overall returns. You will also need to maintain separate minimum balances and margins for each. You will also need to maintain adequate capital in both accounts.

3. Potential for missed opportunities:

Separating your trading and investing activities may limit your profit opportunities. For example, if you have a long-term investment in one account, you may miss out on a short-term trading opportunity in the other account.

Psychological Benefits of Maintaining Two Separate Accounts?

Maintaining separate accounts for broking and trading provides psychological benefits such as reducing the likelihood of fidgeting with long-term holdings and taking on too much margin. When accounts are kept separate, individuals are less likely to pledge their long-term holdings for additional margin or make impulsive trades that could lead to significant losses.

This separation provides a clear distinction between long-term investments and short-term trades, reducing the temptation to blur the lines between the two.

Should You Separate the Two Accounts?

While there are benefits to maintaining separate accounts, there are also some advantages to having both accounts together. One of the main advantages of clubbing your short-term and long-term accounts for trading and investing is convenience. It provides a seamless integration that allows you to trade and manage your portfolio in one place. You can easily buy and sell securities and monitor your portfolio's performance without switching between multiple accounts.

However, separating your regular trading activities from your long-term investments may make sense if you are a frequent trader. This ensures that your goals do not get mixed up, and you can maintain discipline in both your short-term trading and long-term investing activities.

Ultimately, the decision depends on your requirements and the nature of trading and investing. If you want to have a completely separate account only for trading, in that case, having them different might make sense. While if you are starting in the stock markets, you might have them combined.

Summary

While having separate broking accounts can help track gains and losses for both long-term investments and short-term trades, it can also be time-consuming and limit available funds for trading.
Having both accounts together provides convenience, faster transactions, and access to research reports and trading recommendations.
The decision to maintain separate or consolidated brokerage accounts is a personal one that depends on individual investment strategies and financial goals.

Checkout more interesting reads on our blog